Ensure preservation of the Dowling/Fairbank (Vermillion River Delta) Forest Reserve F208
June 18, 2009
Sundog Outfitters owners Jim and Jenny need some support in their efforts to ensure preservation of the Dowling/Fairbank (Vermillion River Delta) Forest Reserve F208. There is a proposal to change this area’s status and allow logging. You can help by firing off an email letter or six (you can copy and personalize the one below).
DATE
YOUR ADDRESS
Scott Dingwall, District Planner
MNR Sudbury District Office
3767 Highway 69 South, Suite 5
Sudbury, Ontario P3G 1E7
Email: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Re: EBR Posting 010-6133 – Proposal to remove Forest Reserve land designation to the Dowling/Fairbank (Vermillion River Delta) Forest Reserve F208
Dear Mr. Dingwall:
I am writing to urge the Ministry of Natural Resources to consider maintaining the status quo of the Dowling/Fairbank (Vermillion River Delta) Forest Reserve F208 in the Sudbury district which has been recently recommended to be re-designated to General Use Area and Enhanced Management Area under the Environmental Bill of Rights (EBR) posting 010-6133.
The largest of several designated Forest Reserves in the Sudbury area, this 1185ha protected area has been created to protect significant natural heritage values including a provincially significant wetland and mature uplands forests, all creating important habitat for a diversity of wildlife. Life science inventories completed for the area concluded that this Forest Reserve contains representation of vegetation landforms found no where else in eco-district 5E-4.
The Dowling/Fairbank Forest Reserve has also created economic opportunities for ecotourism. For example, the owners of Sundog Outfitters, located in Dowling Township, purchased their basecamp property because it was surrounded in protected land and has utilized the Forest Reserve since 2001 as a location to offer sustainable eco-tours year round. They have introduced this area to hundreds of locals and visitors alike and have made a significant investment based on the opportunities the Forest Reserve presented. Now their investment is threatened, as is the landscape in which they work. Removing this protected area will jeopardize their business, and reduce the quality and quantity of programming offered by Sundog. Introducing logging practices will essentially eliminate any backcountry programming that they have established in the area.
Over the past 8 years, local high schools, Cambrian College and Laurentian University have utilized the Forest Reserve as part of their outdoor education, nature-based tourism, winter camping and biology curricula. Several trails exist within the uplands portion of the reserve. These are used for hiking, snowshoeing treks and winter camping outings by Sundog Outfitters, by commercial bear outfitters in the late summer and by local moose and small game hunters in the fall. We can therefore conclude that this forest reserve is an excellent example where several recreational and educational uses presently occur within a land base with little to no user conflict.
Another concern is the fact this area is almost entirely within Greater Sudbury – a community that has been expending considerable efforts to re-vegetate the landscape after decades of harmful industrial activity. The forest reserve has been identified as a pocket of relatively untouched natural area that has essentially escaped harm from industrial impacts of the past. Now this area is once again threatened as forestry activity (i.e. logging) may be allowed should the protection under the banner of the Forest Reserve be lifted.
You have explained that Forest Reserves are considered a threat to mining companies (and specifically junior mining companies) and their shareholders because of the active mining claims and leases within these reserves. Interestingly, the active mining claims and leases within the Dowling/Fairbank Forest Reserve are held exclusively by Vale Inco - not what anyone would consider a ‘junior’ mining company. There has been little to no exploration activity on these claims and leases in the recent past, and there will likely be little to no activity on these claims and leases in the foreseeable future. Vale Inco has thousands of hectares of mining tenure distributed across the entire landscape within the Sudbury region and a few active claims and leases within just over 1000ha of forest reserve will NOT make shareholders uneasy. But it WILL take away from the quality of life of Sudbury area residents and threaten a natural attraction that has enhanced the community’s ecotourism potential.
The Ministry of Natural Resources has excluded the greater public during this exercise entirely. There has been little to no explanation as to how the proposals came to be and what was discussed at the table behind closed doors. Those that were at the table should realize that they were negotiating the fate of others without even being aware of it.
Again, we urge you at this time to allow the Dowling/Fairbank Forest Reserve (F208) to retain the status quo. Meaning, allow the Forest Reserve designation to remain, which will therefore allow mining exploration activity to continue and ensure all other industrial activities are prohibited. This designation has worked fine for 10 years with virtually no conflict.
Please, take this opportunity to assist in maintaining one of the few existing mature green spaces of Greater Sudbury and invest in maintaining the wild spaces of Northern Ontario. This will demonstrate that the provincial government does take ecotourism and natural heritage values protection seriously.
I look forward to your favourable response.
Sincerely,
YOUR NAME
—————————————————-
end of letter
—————————————————————-
info from Jim and Jenny:
Dear family, friends, past clients of Sundog Outfitters, and anyone who finds peace and enjoyment in protected wild spaces,
We are writing today to share some distressing news about the possible future of our beloved backyard. As you may be aware, the Sundog Outfitters basecamp is surrounded by protected land under the banner of the Dowling/Fairbank Forest Reserve (Vermillion River Delta). A recent proposal has been posted on the Environmental Bill of Rights registry (http://www.ebr.gov.on.ca/ERS-WEB-External/ Registry number 010-6133) to re-designate four Forest Reserves in the Sudbury area (including the Dowling/Fairbank) to General Use Area or Enhanced Management Areas. This essentially means they are being reverted back to regular crown land and these forests will no longer be protected from forestry (i.e. logging).
When Forest Reserves were created in 1999, these areas still held active mining claims but once these claims lapsed, it was the intention to create parks in their place. Unfortunately the Provincial Government does not want to keep the Forest Reserve as a land designation - they saw it as only a temporary thing - even though they were working just fine in protecting the forest while allowing for continued mineral exploration. The ‘disentanglement initiative’, as they are calling this elimination of forest reserves, plans to eliminate any overlap of active mining claims with these ‘recommended’ protected areas, and responds to concerns that forest reserves potentially discourage investment in mineral exploration and development (i.e. junior mining companies). Unfortunately, being in the Sudbury area, mining claims don’t seem to lapse that often and 100% of the claims in the Dowling/Fairbank Forest Reserve belong to Vale Inco, who, apparently, never give them up. However, I would definitely NOT consider Inco a junior mining company!!
In the meantime, the local forestry industry is currently writing their forest management plan for 2010 - 2020 and we have been told by both the Sustainable Forest License holder (a consortium of companies that have access to cutting the forests in the Sudbury area) AND the Ministry of Natural Resources, that they would like to include these forest reserves as part of that plan. This could mean the chain saws may be in there as early as next year.
And there’s more…this proposal was first posted in 2006 but a decision was deferred due to the amount of public opposition regarding the proposed re-designation. Thank you to those of you who supported us back then! Now, it seems the ‘dust has settled’ so they’re trying to put it forward once again.
.
We are asking you now, once again, for your support in opposing this proposal and asking the government to retain the status quo land designation of the Dowling/Fairbank Forest Reserve.
To make it easy for you to provide feedback, we have attached a form letter that you may send in to the MNR, or we have listed below reasons why we oppose this proposal. You may pick and choose from this list as you see fit and include them in your comments if you wish:
* When Forest Reserves were created in 1999, there was no indication that these areas would be eliminated from the protected areas of Ontario. In fact the opposite is true: these areas were promised to eventually be fully protected parks.
* There was a reason for this protection - the Dowling/Fairbank Forest Reserve holds a large and excellent representation of unique vegetative landforms. To lift this protection and allow forestry practices would be irresponsible - especially in a city (Greater Sudbury) that has been scarred by environmental devastation for over a century.
*
The largest of several designated Forest Reserves in the Sudbury area, this 1185ha protected area has been created to protect significant natural heritage values including a provincially significant wetland and unique uplands forests, all creating important habitat for a diversity of wildlife. Life science inventories completed for the area concluded that this Forest Reserve contains representation of vegetation landforms found no where else in eco-district 5E-4.
* Local business owners Jenny Martindale and Jim Little made a significant investment, purchased their property and started their business Sundog Outfitters adjacent to the Vermillion River Delta because it was a protected area and offered many opportunities for ecotourism programming. Removing this protected area will jeopardize their business, and reduce the quality and quantity of programming offered by Sundog.
* Since 2001, Sundog Outfitters has introduced hundreds of people to this beautiful wilderness area. Introducing logging practices will essentially eliminate any backcountry programming that they have established in the area.
* Over the past 8 years, local high schools, Cambrian College and Laurentian University have utilized the Forest Reserve as part of their outdoor education, nature-based tourism, winter camping and biology curricula.
* Several trails exist within the uplands portion of the reserve. These are used for hiking, snowshoeing treks and winter camping outings by Sundog Outfitters, by commercial bear outfitters in the late summer and by local moose and small game hunters in the fall. We can therefore conclude that this forest reserve is an excellent example where several recreational and educational uses presently occur within a land base with little to no user conflict.
* There is absolutely nothing wrong with keeping the status quo and maintaining the Dowling/Fairbank Forest Reserve designation for the long term. It has been working fine with no issues for 10 years. Especially in this case where Vale Inco holds 100% of the claims (and not a junior mining company). Maintaining this small piece of protected land will not affect investment and development at Vale Inco.
* The Ministry of Natural Resources has excluded the public during this exercise entirely. There has been little to no explanation as to how the proposals came to be and what was discussed at the table behind closed doors. Those that were at the table should realize that they were negotiating the fate of others without even being aware of it.
Comments should be sent to: Scott Dingwall, District Planner, MNR Sudbury District Office, 3767 Highway 69 South, Suite 5, Sudbury, Ontario, P3G 1E7. Email: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address). Please note that the deadline for comments is July 11, 2009 (less than a month!). If you would like to copy other politicians, we have included their emails below.
Ontario Minister of Natural Resources Donna Cansfield: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Nickel Belt Member of Parliament France Gelinas:fgelinas-co@ndp.on.ca and .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Mayor of Greater Sudbury John Rodriguez: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Ontario MNR Regional Director (Northeast) Eric Doidge: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Ontario MNR District Manager Ed Tear: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
We thank you in advance if you choose to submit comments and are deeply grateful for your concern regarding this matter.
We’ll keep you posted on the final decision. Let’s hope the trees and forest critters win!
Sincerely,
Jenny & Jim
Sundog Outfitters
